Signs of Primary Care Success
When a company or an industry
becomes truly successful, one of the first real signs of that success is a new
level of criticism aimed its way.
Recently, one of our neurosurgeon colleagues wrote a post critical of primary care that appeared on the Neurosurgery Blog. It then was picked up by the Association of American Medical Colleges' blog Wing of Zock.
In the blog, Robert Harbaugh, M.D.,
does a grave disservice to family physicians, medical students, and our country
by misrepresenting and attacking primary care medicine.
Unwilling to let his message stand
unopposed, I worked with the AAFP's public relations staff to craft a response
to Harbaugh's blog as posted on the Wing of Zock blog, and we are very happy that
they posted it.
As our country begins to move toward investing in primary care as an effective way to bend our unsustainable cost curve of health care, we can expect increasing push back from those who either do not understand the real effectiveness of primary care or who stand to lose in this important transformation.
Our Academy will respond forcefully
to these outliers, for the health of our patients, our practices and our
Primary Care Needs Are No Myth
In "The Primary Care Shibboleth: Debunking the Myth," Dr. Robert E. Harbaugh (a neurosurgeon) does a grave disservice to family physicians and medical students who value the professional satisfaction, intellectual challenges and career-long patient relationships of primary care.
Dr. Robert Harbaugh, M.D., is misinformed.
Primary care should be the critical foundation of our health care system. A wealth of published, credible data supports the value of primary care and prevention:
- Health care systems with a strong primary care sector are associated with reduced health care costs and improved quality of care.
- Primary care physicians decrease health care utilization through effective preventive care and enhanced coordination of care.
- Patients who have a family physician as their usual source of care have lower total medical care costs.
Harbaugh wrote, "The United States has a relatively high concentration of primary care physicians and a relatively low concentration of (sub)specialists compared to the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) average of all countries." Unfortunately, this statistic is skewed by counting all of "internal medicine" as a primary care specialty, erroneously including medical subspecialists as primary care. The truth is the ratio of primary care and subspecialty care proven to produce the best outcomes is now out of balance in the United States and threatens to get worse. Currently, less than 20 percent of medical students who enter internal medicine residencies go on to practice primary care.
Harbaugh asks if anyone believes that by investing more in primary care, we can prevent people from getting sick and save money. It may come as a surprise to Dr. Harbaugh, but not only do our nation's health care policy experts acknowledge the value of investing in primary care, but so do many of the nation's top business executives.
Harbaugh misses the point of primary care by describing it as "a brief meeting with a physician who tells patients what they already know." Primary care's strength is in continuity, the relationships formed with patients over years that allow early detection and intervention in medical illnesses. Family physicians are trained in effective behavioral change methods proven to make a difference in the health of their patients. Investing in primary care and the patient-centered medical home reduces overall system costs by reducing unnecessary hospitalizations and unnecessary emergency department visits.
Overall, Harbaugh fails to acknowledge the very real cost and patient safety differences in primary, secondary and tertiary prevention. His example from his own practice is the carotid endarterectomy, an example of tertiary prevention. Indeed, if a patient had access to a primary care physician to help control blood pressure, smoking cessation, and prescribe statins when necessary, the patient might even avoid the need for this procedure with its associated high costs and surgical risks.
Furthermore, we cannot hide from the truth. Primary care is among the lowest paid physician specialties in the United States, a travesty given the overall value that primary care brings to our patients, communities and the health care system. This huge income disparity has a profoundly negative impact on our country's future workforce. The average medical student today has more than $161,000 in education debt after medical school. Data increasingly show that debt and earning potential are swaying student specialty choice.
To close the gap in medical student specialty choice, the Council on Graduate Medical Education's 20th report recommended that primary care physicians be paid at 70 percent of subspecialists' pay. When our Canadian colleagues faced a similar decrease in primary care student interest 10 years ago, they increased the mean salary of family physicians and now have more medical students entering family medicine than ever.
Harbaugh interprets the data narrowly and quite selectively. The professional societies representing primary care have never advocated "robbing Peter to pay Paul" by increasing payments to primary care physicians at the expense of surgical specialties and other subspecialties. The AAFP's position has always been that savings from preventing avoidable emergency department use, hospitalizations, readmissions, procedures and tests will more than pay for improved payment for primary care.
Harbaugh says patients are the priority, and we couldn't agree more. If we are to address the toughest challenges in medicine, we must respect the value and expertise of all our medical colleagues -- primary care and subspecialists alike. By bringing physicians together, we can have a profound and far-reaching impact on medicine. But most importantly, we can do what is best for the health and well-being of our patients.
Jeff Cain, M.D., is the president of the AAFP.
Want to use this article elsewhere? Get Permissions
Search This Blog
Subscribe to receive e-mail notifications when the blog is updated.